You are here: Home > 90+ Point Wines

Top Rated Wines

DrinkUpNY proudly offers an extensive selection of 90 Point Wines that have received excellent wine ratings from Wine Spectator, Wine Advocate, Wine Enthusiast and more! Browse through the best rated wines from around the world to find the perfect wine for casual gatherings or special occasions. Choose from crisp white wines, decadent dessert wines and top rated red wines from France, Spain, Italy, Portugal and many other premier wine-making regions.

Sort By:
Page of 6
Alvaro Castro DAC Tinto 2012 (Dao, Portugal) Alvear's Cream Montilla-Moriles NV (Andalucia, Spain) Alvear Solera "1927" Montilla-Moriles Pedro Ximenez NV (Andalucia, Spain) (375ml)
List Price: $20.99
Our Price: $18.00
Sale Price: $15.99
You save $5.00!
List Price: $21.99
Our Price: $19.00
Sale Price: $16.99
You save $5.00!
List Price: $29.99
Our Price: $26.00
Sale Price: $22.99
You save $7.00!
Alvaro Castro DAC Tinto Alvears Cream Montilla Alvear Solera 1927 Pedro Ximenez

93 Points - Wine & Spirits
Alvaro Castro DAC Tinto is a blend of Touriga Nacional, Jaen, Roriz and Alfrocheiro, grown in granite soils with rows of sand and clay. The vines are between 3 and 65 years old and located at an average altitude of 550 meters. The result is a light-bodied, bright and graceful wine offering notes of crushed herbs, cracked green peppercorns and fresh red fruit, leading to a long finish accented by hints of peppery spice.

91 Points - Wine Advocate
Alvear's Cream Montilla is a deep walnut color with enticing aromas of caramel, roasted nuts, and vanilla. The palate is sweet, balanced, and flat-out delicious; enjoy this rich wine after dinner, either sipped alone or paired with dessert.

96 Points - Wine Advocate
This is a deep, unctuous, and intense dessert wine made from a solera started in 1927, and is a striking value. Rich in color and flavor, this deep mahogany wine displays layered and complex chocolate, prune, caramel, walnut, and candied tangerine characteristics while maintaining impeccable balance.
Avignonesi Vino Nobile di Montepulciano 2010 (Tuscany, Italy) Blandy's 15 Year Old Malmsey Madeira NV (Madeira, Portugal) (500ml) Bodega Catena Zapata "Catena" Malbec 2012 (Mendoza, Argentina)
List Price: $36.99
Our Price: $34.00
Sale Price: $29.99
You save $7.00!
List Price: $52.99
Our Price: $50.00
Sale Price: $43.99
You save $9.00!
List Price: $29.99
Our Price: $25.00
Sale Price: $21.99
You save $8.00!
Avignonesi Vino Nobile di Montepulciano Blandy's 15 Year Old Malmsey Madeira Bodega Catena Zapata Catena Malbec

91 Points - Wine Spectator
This Vino Nobile is made up primarily of Prugnolo Gentile (Sangiovese) and has a silky palate, rich cherry fruit and a full body. This is a great alternative to more expensive Brunellos.

Out of Stock.

92 Points - Wine Spectator

Blandy's 15 Year Old Malmsey is sweet, full bodied and complex, with earthy notes of dried fruit, toffee, vanilla, and oak on the nose and palate. The lingering finish displays hints of roasted nuts and dark chocolate. It is an excellent accompaniment to cakes, fruit, chocolate pudding, and rich cheeses.

90 Points - Wine Spectator
This Malbec has enticing aromas of crushed blueberry and raspberry, with a juicy texture and well-integrated toast and mineral notes. You'll savor another burst of luscious fruit on the finish.
Bodega Catena Zapata "Nicolas Catena Zapata" Red 2009 (Mendoza, Argentina) Bodegas Breca "Breca" Old Vine Garnacha 2011 (Aragon, Spain) Bodegas Ponce "Clos Lojen" Bobal Manchuela 2013 (Castilla La Mancha, Spain)
List Price: $149.99
Our Price: $143.00
Sale Price: $130.99
You save $19.00!
List Price: $21.99
Our Price: $18.00
Sale Price: $15.99
You save $6.00!
List Price: $18.99
Our Price: $15.00
Sale Price: $12.99
You save $6.00!
Bodega Catena Zapata Nicolas Catena Zapata Red Bodegas Breca Breca Old Vine Garnacha Bodegas Ponce "Clos Lojen" Bobal Manchuela

95 Points - Wine Advocate
94 Points - Wine Spectator
Nicolas Catena Zapata is made from a selection of the best grapes grown in the Catena Zapata vineyards. The wine is only produced in outstanding vintage years. Made in an elegantly modern style, this exceptionally age-worthy wine is deeply aromatic with notes of dark fruit, anise, baking spices, and earth. The palate is layered, deep, and perfectly structured with flavors of blackberry, cherry, raspberry, violet, dark chocolate, and leather. Sweet tannins carry through the long finish.

91 Points - International Wine Cellar
Matured for twenty-one months in French oak barrels, Bodegas Breca "Breca" Old Vine Garnacha displays intense aromas of blackberry, raspberry and violet, accented by notes of anise and mineral. Concentrated flavors of dark berry, wildflowers, lavender and vanilla merge with a lively hint of peppery spice on the impressively long finish.

90 Points - International Wine Cellar
The nose starts of with intense aromas of black raspberry and cherry, with hint of smoke and mineral notes. The palate of this wine starts of with youthful notes of Strawberry and plum which progress into fleshier and richer offerings of sweet red and dark berry flavors with hint of chocolate and herbs.
Bodegas Ramirez "Ramirez de la Piscina" Reserva 2007 (Rioja, Spain) Calem Vintage Port 2007 (Douro Valley, Portugal) Campbells Rutherglen Muscat NV (Victoria, Australia) (375ml)
List Price: $25.99
Our Price: $23.00
Sale Price: $19.99
You save $6.00!
List Price: $66.99
Our Price: $61.00
Sale Price: $54.99
You save $12.00!
List Price: $24.99
Our Price: $23.00
Sale Price: $20.99
You save $4.00!
Bodegas Ramirez Ramirez de la Piscina Reserva Calem Vintage Port Campbells Rutherglen Muscat

91 Points - International Wine Cellar
Aged in French and American oak for 18 months, Bodegas Ramirez "Ramirez de la Piscina" Reserva is a bold, powerful, yet nuanced Rioja with abundant raspberry, cherry, vanilla, spice and earth characteristics. Assertive tannins and balanced acidity last through the lengthy finish. It will continue to evolve for another two to three years and can be enjoyed through 2025.

90 Points - Wine Enthusiast
Calem Vintage Port is a complex, full-bodied wine boasting intense aromas of blackberry, plum and boysenberry, accented by lovely floral notes. The rich, off-dry palate features concentrated notes of beautifully ripe fruit, framed by strong, dusty tannins and firm acidity. A subtle spiciness lingers through the finish. Drink through 2027.

94 Points - Wine Enthusiast
92 Points - Wine Advocate
92 Points - Wine Spectator
This spectacular fortified Muscat is a deep, unctuous, and perfectly sweet wine with incredible richness and intensity. Beautiful notes of caramel, toffee, raisins and molasses explode on the palate.